Securing a Letter of Recommendation from an Unfamiliar Teacher: Strategies and Tips
Navigating the process of obtaining letters of recommendation can be challenging, especially when you need a reference from a teacher you haven’t had direct experience with. If you’re preparing for college applications and considering recommending letters from educators in your academic journey, understanding how to approach such requests is crucial.
Scenario Overview
Suppose you’re aiming to pursue majors in journalism and political science. Your school’s offerings include only one dedicated journalism instructor for seniors next year and a journalism club advisor. However, these two educators have different teaching styles and do not interact much. You’re contemplating who would be the best choice for a recommendation letter and how to approach them.
Choosing the Right Recommender
Evaluate Your Relationships and Their Relevance
-
The Journalism Teacher: Despite being the only one for seniors, you haven’t taken their class yet. If you’re considering asking them, think about whether you’ve engaged with their work or have relevant interactions that could support your request.
-
The Journalism Club Advisor: You’ve known this teacher since seventh grade, providing a solid foundation of familiarity. If they’ve observed your skills, enthusiasm, and dedication, they could serve as a credible recommender.
Aligning Your Goals
Since your intended majors are journalism and political science, consider which teacher’s insight best reflects your abilities and interests relevant to these fields. A teacher who has seen you demonstrate writing, critical thinking, or leadership traits will strengthen your application.
How to Approach Teachers for a Recommendation Letter
For Teachers You Haven’t Had in Class
-
Build a Connection: Even if you haven’t taken their class, find opportunities to interact—attend their office hours, participate in discussions, or join clubs or activities they oversee.
-
Highlight Your Goals: When requesting a letter, clearly explain your college pursuits, why you’d appreciate their support, and how your qualities align with your chosen majors.
-
Provide Context: Share specific achievements, projects, or experiences that relate to their subject area, making it easier for them to write a personalized recommendation.
For the Club Advisor You’ve Known Since Middle School
-
Leverage Your Relationship: Remind them of your journey, involvement, and growth over the years.
-
Explain Your Intentions: Clarify why you’re seeking their recommendation and how it can contribute to your future plans.
General Tips
- Request Respectfully and Early: Give ample time—ideally several weeks—for them to draft a