Requesting Clarification on Essay Grades: Is It Appropriate and How to Do It Effectively?
Receiving feedback on academic assignments is an important part of the learning process, but what happens when a grade comes with minimal commentary? Many students find themselves wondering whether it’s acceptable to reach out to instructors or teaching assistants (TAs) for clarification, especially when a grade reduction seems unexplained.
In one common scenario, a student received their first essay grade and was pleased with their overall performance. However, they noted that they lost points in the “grammar and writing style” category, according to the rubric. The TA’s only comment was a simple “nice job,” providing no specific guidance or feedback on how to improve. Naturally, the student considered sending an email to inquire about areas for improvement—despite not being unhappy with the grade itself.
Is It Appropriate to Seek Clarification?
Absolutely. Asking for clarification can be beneficial, provided it’s done professionally and respectfully. Teachers and TAs generally appreciate students who demonstrate genuine interest in understanding assessment criteria and improving their skills. Such inquiries also show that you are committed to your academic growth, which can foster positive communication and learning opportunities.
How to Approach Your Instructor or TA
-
Be Polite and Respectful: Begin your message with gratitude for their feedback and acknowledge their time constraints.
-
Be Specific: Mention which part of the grade you are referring to— in this case, “grammar and writing style”— and ask for specific suggestions for improvement.
-
Express Your Intentions Clearly: Clarify that your goal is to enhance your skills for future assignments, not to contest the grade.
-
Keep It Concise: Respect their time by asking clear, straightforward questions.
Sample Email Template:
Subject: Clarification on Essay Feedback and Tips for Improvement
Dear [Instructor/TA Name],
I hope this message finds you well. Thank you for grading my recent essay and for the overall feedback. I noticed that I lost points in the “grammar and writing style” category, and I would appreciate any specific suggestions you might have on how I can strengthen these aspects in my future work. My goal is to improve continuously and ensure I meet the expectations moving forward.
Thank you very much for your time and guidance.
Best regards,
[Your Name]
Balancing Your Curiosity with Respect for Their Time
While it’s natural to seek clarity, remember that TAs and instructors often have multiple